The Lady in the Well
By Robert A. Waters
Maisie Gray was pushed into the abandoned pit. Arms flailing and her screams piercing the silence, she fell. She couldn't see beneath her because of the darkness, but within seconds, she landed with a jolt on a rock-hard surface. The bottom of the well held three feet of water and had a strange toxic smell.
She must have known she would die in this pit.
Above, the man who'd shoved her into the abyss yelled, "I know you're still alive." Then he leaned into the opening in the well and began firing gunshots down at Maisie. Some of the bullets rocketed straight into her body, while others ricocheted off the centuries-old stone walls. An autopsy later revealed she'd been hit with multiple rounds in the head and "all over her body."
Did she have time to think of her son and daughters? Or her husband? Did she pray to God? Whatever thoughts she had couldn't have lasted long.
Because of an evil stranger, she died alone in that poisonous well.
At about 2:30 A.M., December 10, 1984, a customer stopped at the Majik Mart in Attalla, Alabama. Finding the store empty and the cash drawer open, she called the Etowah County Sheriff's Office. Thus began a month-long search for the missing 57-year-old clerk.
Maisie had been working there for only three weeks. During that time, she'd sold more beer and soft drinks than she ever knew existed. A friendly country girl, the Gadsden Times reported "she liked nothing better than sitting down with a couple of friends and draining a coffee pot while they talked."
Maisie was alone when Michael Eugene Thompson walked into the store. He looked around, making sure no one else was there. Then he pulled a long-barrel .22-caliber pistol out of his pants and stuck it in Maisie's face. Quickly complying when he demanded she empty the cash register, she handed him exactly $72.23.
She'd done what the company had trained her to do. "Don't fight," she was told. "Give the robber the money in the cash drawer and he'll leave. That way, you won't get hurt."
Instead of leaving alone, however, Thompson demanded that Maisie go outside with him. Keeping the gun trained on his victim, he marched her to his car and forced her into the trunk. For more than an hour, he drove randomly through the countryside.
Thompson had grown up in the hills in nearby Blount County. He knew many places to hide a body. Before he got hooked on dope, he'd hunted and fished the area. Those were the few pleasant memories he had of his childhood. Now he couldn't go more than a day without getting stoned. The cash Maisie had handed over should get him what he needed. At least for a few hours.
But he had to get rid of her. He finally thought of a place where her body would never be found. Thompson recalled several abandoned wells located in the desolate woods he used to roam. He later confessed. "I left [the store] and went to Blount County," he told investigators, "where I pushed her in the well and shot a bunch of shots down in the well, and I run out of [bullets]."
The Birmingham Post-Herald wrote that Gray's "body was found a month later when Etowah County Sheriff Roy McDowell received a tip that Mrs. Gray's body was in a 24-foot well about 5 miles north of Snead. McDowell testified he learned of the location after Shirley Smith Franklin, who had lived with Thompson, called his office and later talked to him in person."
Franklin explained her involvement. After getting some "shells," (as she called the bullets) for the pistol, she informed cops that Thompson grabbed a burgundy-colored housecoat off the bed. According to Franklin, her boyfriend dragged her out of the house and forced her to go with him. While driving to Blount County, he told her about kidnapping the clerk, throwing her in the well, and shooting her.
Franklin said they stopped in front of the well. Then he set the housecoat on fire and forced Franklin to hold it down in the well so he could see the bottom. She later testified that he reloaded the gun and began firing again into the well. After eight or ten shots, they left and went home.
One month after her murder, because of Shirley Franklin's confession, several agencies, including Blount County Sheriff J. C. Carr, arrived at the well.
The Post Herald reported that that it took four and a half hours for the Oneonta Fire Department and a representative from the State Forensic Science Lab to remove Maisie's body from "the 24 foot well in the middle of a small orchard on a one-lane dirt road. Rescuers entered the well numerous times in the effort, which was interrupted at times so an exhaust fan could be used to remove gases from the well. Carr said methane gas was found in the well and rescuers initially had to use air packs when going in."
Sheriff McDowell said "the body was lodged against the side of the narrow well, just above the water, which was three feet deep."
Michael Eugene Thompson was tried in Blount County. At trial, he tried to convince the jury that even though he kidnapped Maisie and threw her down the well, his girlfriend had done the actual shooting. The jury didn't buy it. Convicted of capital murder and kidnapping, he was sentenced to death.
Then the seemingly endless appeals began. After nearly two decades, Maisie's children had gotten fed up with it all. Evelyn Elliott, the victim's daughter, told reporters that "he's been found guilty of kidnapping and killing her. He took a life. There's got to be a penalty for doing things like that. I would like to tell him to be a man. To admit his sins and face the consequences like a man."
On March 13, 2003, Thompson drifted off to his final sleep after being administered a lethal injection. After the execution, James Rodgers, Maisie's son, said, "I don't feel sorry for him. It was his actions that brought all this about."
Evelyn Elliott said, "He died a very painless death. I wish my mother had a chance to feel no pain."





















